The Saint in New York is a full-length novel, and Charteris’ 15th Saint book. Saint expert Burl Barer indicates that The Saint in New York was the first “bestseller” of the Simon Templar series, and was the book that established Charteris as a literary celebrity in America and Britain. Due to the book’s popularity, it became the first Simon Templar story to be purchased by a film company (RKO Radio Pictures), and it was eventually released as a film in 1938.
First, Charteris neatly deals with the problem of introducing the Saint to a new continent and a new readership by having Chief-Inspector Teal send a dossier of the Saint’s previous activities over to New York detective Inspector John Fernack. This dossier provides the opening of the prologue.
As might be expected, the story is grittier and more down-to-earth than usual, and involves crime lords, gangsters, henchmen, and corrupt high-ranking New York City officials in charge of a legal system that doesn’t always achieve justice for the victim or punishment for the guilty. The situation obviously needs the Saint’s own brand of self-administered justice, which puts him in opposition to the Police Department.
Fernack explains the problem:
“Up at the top of this city,” he said slowly, “there’s a political organization called Tammany Hall. They’re the boys who fill all the public offices, and before you were born they’d made electioneering into such an exact science that they just don’t even think about it any more. They turn out their voters like an army parade, their hired hoodlums guard the polls, and their employees count the votes. The boss of Tammany Hall is a man called Robert Orcread, and the nickname he gave himself is Honest Bob. Outside the City Hall there’s a fine bit of a statue called Civic Virtue, and inside there’s the biggest collection of crooks and grafters that ever ran a city.
“There’s a district attorney named Marcus Yeald who’s so crooked you could use him to pull corks with; and his cases come up before a row of judges like Nather. Things are different here from what they are in your country. Over here our judges get elected; and every time a case comes up before them they have to sit down and figure out what the guy’s political pull is, or maybe somebody higher up just tells ‘em so they won’t make any mistake, because if a judge sends a guy up the river who’s got a big political drag there’s going to be somebody else sittin’ in his chair when the next election comes round.